Skip to content

Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative Announces Termination of the Cyclosporine Treatment Arm for Critically Ill COVID-19 Patients in the I-SPY COVID Trial

Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative (QLHC), sponsor of the I-SPY COVID Trial, announces that the cyclosporine arm of the study has been terminated for futility. Cyclosporine, a calcineurin inhibitor and a well-known and commonly prescribed immunosuppressant medication, is best known for its efficacy in the prevention of solid organ transplant rejection.

SAN FRANCISCO, Aug. 8, 2022 /PRNewswire/ — Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative (QLHC), sponsor of the I-SPY COVID Trial, announces that the cyclosporine arm of the study has been terminated for futility. Cyclosporine, a calcineurin inhibitor and a well-known and commonly prescribed immunosuppressant medication, is best known for its efficacy in the prevention of solid organ transplant rejection.

Due to its anti-inflammatory properties and other potentially beneficial actions, and previous published reports of efficacy in critically ill patients, cyclosporine has been suggested for the treatment of patients hospitalized with COVID-19.i One of the defining characteristics of COVID-19 related lung injury is an overactive immune response and ‘cytokine storm’ – a difficult-to-treat type of inflammation. The I-SPY investigators hypothesized that cyclosporine’s ability to suppress the cytokine storm would reduce inflammatory injury in severely ill COVID-19 patients.

To minimize potential toxicity a relatively low oral dose of 5 mg/kg/day for a duration of 5 days was selected to be administered to patients randomized into the cyclosporine arm. The subjects received the backbone therapy (standard of care) in addition to cyclosporine. The control patients received the standard of care backbone therapy, including dexamethasone and remdesivir.

The I-SPY COVID Trial was designed to rapidly screen agents that show promise for two primary endpoints: reducing the time to recovery (defined as reduction in supplemental oxygen demand) or risk of mortality in critically ill COVID-19 patients. The study utilizes QLHC’s adaptive platform trial design methodology, which focuses on the simultaneous, efficient assessment of multiple investigational agents. The testing of cyclosporine was discontinued at the recommendation of the trial Data Monitoring Committee (DMC) after 108 subjects were randomized to the cyclosporine arm and analyzed in the intent-to-treat (ITT) population compared to 127 subjects who were concurrently randomized to the control arm. The probability that cyclosporine could reduce time to recovery was estimated to be 15.4%; the probability that the cyclosporine arm was superior to the concurrent arm to reduce mortality was estimated to be 54.8%. As a result, neither the recovery nor mortality outcomes met the pre-defined criteria for cyclosporine’s graduation from the trial. It was also observed that a higher fraction of subjects in the cyclosporine arm reported adverse events possibly related to the study agent compared to that of the concurrent control group—although this is difficult to interpret in an open label trial. Given these data, the cyclosporine arm was closed to further enrollment.

Angela Haczku, MD, PhD and Ari Moskowitz, MD, MPH led the study of this agent in the I-SPY COVID Trial. As noted by Drs. Haczku and Moskowitz, “Although cyclosporine at the selected low dose and duration of treatment did not accomplish the primary endpoints set originally in the study design, we are currently analyzing the effects of this drug on immune biomarkers and other disease outcomes. There are several questions that remain and would be important to address. For example: What are the factors that contributed to the change in patient enrollment into the cyclosporine arm during the second year of the pandemic? What is the relationship of blood cyclosporine concentrations to biomarkers of COVID-19? How did the well-established and extensively detailed list of adverse cyclosporine effects influence the frequency of reporting in this open-label trial?”

One of our future goals is to improve biomarker classification of COVID-19 severe illness,” commented Dr. Laura Esserman, co-principal investigator of the I-SPY Trials. “This effort, led by Dr. Carolyn Calfee at the University of California, San Francisco, and the I-SPY COVID Trial Biomarker Working Group, is a critical part of the I-SPY COVID trial which will hopefully help us to find effective agents for this incredibly challenging and devastating disease.”

Investigation into additional agents via the I-SPY COVID Trial is ongoing and remains an urgent priority for QLHC and its partners. The I-SPY COVID Trial now includes 33 sites as well as leaders in pulmonary and critical care centers from around the country.

The I-SPY COVID Trial is a collaboration between members of QLHC and pharmaceutical partners and the United States government (USG). This work is supported in part by the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority, part of the Adminstration for Stratefgic Preparedness and Response within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and the Department of Defense (DoD) Joint Program Executive Office for Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear Defense, in collaboration with the Medical CBRN Defense Consortium. The Defense Threat Reduction Agency enables USG and international partners to counter and deter weapons of mass destruction and emerging threats. Effort was sponsored by the U.S. government under Other Transaction number W15QKN-16-9-1002 between the MCDC, and the government. The US government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright notation thereon.The views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements, either expressed or implied, of the U.S. government.

About Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative

Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative is a 501C(3) charitable organization established in 2005 as a collaboration between medical researchers at University of California, San Francisco and Silicon Valley entrepreneurs. Our mission is to integrate high-impact research with clinical processes and systems technology, resulting in improved data management and information systems, greater access to clinical trial matching and sponsorship, and greater benefit to providers, patients and researchers. Our goal is to improve and save lives. Quantum Leap provides operational, financial, and regulatory oversight to the I-SPY Trials. For more information, visit www.QuantumLeapHealth.org.

About the I-SPY COVID Trial

The I-SPY COVID Trial (Investigation of Serial Studies to Predict Your COVID Therapeutic Response with Biomarker Integration and Adaptive Learning) is an adaptive platform trial designed to increase trial efficiency by minimizing the number of participants and time required to evaluate experimental and/or repurposed drugs. The focus of the trial is to improve outcomes for severely-ill COVID-19 patients—those who require at least 6L of high-flow oxygen either by mask or nasal cannula, known as level 5 on the World Health Organization (WHO) COVID scale, an 8-point ordinal scale of clinical severity status. The primary endpoints include the time to achieve level 4 or less for at least 48 hours on the WHO COVID scale, a decrease in the duration of time on a ventilator, and a decrease in mortality.

The I-SPY COVID Trial is sponsored and managed by Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative. For more information, visit www.quantumleaphealth.org or www.ispytrials.org.

Forward Looking Statements

This press release contains forward-looking statements. Statements in this press release that are not purely historical are forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements are made as of the date of this press release, and the Company assumes no obligation to update the forward-looking statements, or to update the reasons why actual results could differ from those projected in the forward-looking statements, except as required by law. Investors should consult all the information set forth herein and should also refer to the risk factor disclosure set forth in the reports and other documents the Company files with the SEC available at www.sec.gov.

i Galvez-Romero, J.L. et al (2021). Cyclosporine A plus low-dose steroid treatment in COVID-19 improves clinical outcomes in patients with moderate to severe disease: A pilot study, Journal of Internal Medicine, 289; 906- 920. https://doi.org/10.1111/joim.13223

Media Contact:
Jacqueline Murray
(415) 710-6829
j.murray@quantumleaphealth.org

SOURCE Quantum Leap Healthcare Collaborative

Related Links

http://www.quantumleaphealth.org

For more information, email karyn.digiorgio@quantumleaphealth.org

Contact Us
Access & Diversity
QLHC in the News
Working at QLHC
Contact Us

Deborah Romer

Deborah’s breast cancer diagnosis in late 2022 catalyzed her interest in breast cancer research and patient advocacy following a complicated diagnosis. She is pleased to be participating as a patient advocate at UCSF, as well as with state, national and international groups, and has channeled her research and health care background in her advocacy work.

Deborah is a member of the National Breast Cancer Coalition and attended their Project Lead Science Training program in the summer of 2024, and will complete their Public Policy Institute in 2025. She serves on the Research Committee of the Lobular Breast Cancer Alliance (LBCA) and has been a grant reviewer for ASCO and LBCA. She begun working with Dr. Rita Mukhtar at UCSF on lobular breast cancer research and served on a panel for the Annual UCSF Breast Oncology Program Retreat. Deborah joined as a new member of the UCSF I-SPY Patient Advocate Panel in 2025 and serves as a Board member of Breast Cancer Care & Research Fund which links education, research and care to end breast cancer.

Throughout Deborah’s 30 plus year career in health care administration, she has worked to make health care more inclusive, accessible, equitable and personal. She started her health care career at the Stanford School of Medicine and then worked with several hospitals and health systems, including Kaiser Permanente where she worked for 22 years, serving as a medical group administrator and hospital CEO in Northern California, then at the National level as Vice President for Patient and Service Quality and as an Executive for National Quality and Board Governance.

Deborah is passionate about the importance of evidence-based research and multi-specialty team collaboration in solving problems and is committed to advancing breast cancer research, to supporting researchers, clinicians and patients, and to ensuring that the patients’ perspective is integrated into research, clinical trials and care. She has a BA with Highest Honors in Sociology and Research Methods from the University of California, Santa Cruz and a MBA from the Anderson School of Management at UCLA. She enjoys opera, jazz and the performing arts, as well as hiking, dancing and traveling, and is excited to be moving back to San Francisco in spring, 2025.

Tracey Heather

Advocate Liaison

As Patient Engagement Lead at Quantum Leap, I manage follow-up data projects for the I-SPY 2 Trial, develop strategies to strengthen patient engagement, and oversee the I-SPY Advocate group. After six successful years raising funds to support Quantum’s mission, I embraced this new role last summer, drawn by the opportunity to make a direct impact on the patients we serve. Each day brings new challenges and insights, and I especially enjoy supporting and collaborating with our inspiring I-SPY Advocates.

Outside of work, I am pursuing a Master of Public Administration with a focus on nonprofit management at SF State. I’m passionate about trail running, skiing, live music, camping, traveling, and collegiate gymnastics—my daughter competes at Oregon State. For the past 5 years, I have volunteered with SF CASA as a mentor to an incredible 18-year-old foster youth whose resilience continually reminds me of life’s true priorities.

Carolyn Clark Beedle

Carolyn Clark Beedle, a 2023 breast cancer survivor, joined the advocate program after successful completion of treatment with the UCSF Breast Oncology Program. Her experience working with a patient advocate during her TNBC treatment led to an understanding that empowering women to advocate for their own health and healthcare will contribute to improved health outcomes and broader access to care. Carolyn began advocating for cancer patients and their families during her treatment, now is a member of the Breast Science Advocacy Core (BSAC) with the UCSF Breast Oncology Program, and currently shares information and research with CFNP associates at La Clinica in the Bay Area to inform and empower their patient population.

Carolyn is continuing her on the ground training as an advocate reviewer with both Quantum Health and BSAC and is enrolled in the Patient Advocacy Training in Health Science course with Stanford Medicine. Her 30+ career in corporate marketing/communications, program development and non-profit leadership augmented by her breast cancer treatment experience serves Carolyn well in representing and communicating the patient voice and perspective.

She received her BA (History/English Lit) and MA (Public History/Research and Record Management) from the University of San Diego, is a proud fifth generation San Franciscan, and active board member with numerous non-profits that support social work and the arts.

Silver Alkhafaji

Silver Alkhafaji is a PhD candidate in the Pharmaceutical Sciences and Pharmacogenomics (PSPG) program at UCSF. She received her Bachelor of Science in Chemical Biology from UC Berkeley. Prior to UCSF, she worked in the Clinical Pharmacology Department at Genentech. Silver’s current research focuses on non-invasive liquid biopsies to predict response and side effects of immunotherapies and endocrine therapies in early-stage breast cancer participants in I-SPY 2.

Silver is interested in clinical outcomes research to advance precision medicine and improve cancer patients’ quality of life. She is passionate about health equity, inclusive research, patient advocacy, and women’s health.
Silver volunteers at the Patient and Family Cancer Support Center at UCSF where she assists in patient navigation and connecting patients and their families with resources that improve their healthcare experience while receiving cancer treatments and/or during survivorship. 

Through her DEI work in her PhD program, Silver raises awareness around issues related to social justice and community building through organizing community-centered events. Additionally, she is a member of the Life Sciences Career Advisory Council at Thrive Scholars, where she enjoys supporting college students of color from economically disadvantaged communities in providing the opportunities they need to thrive at top colleges and in high-trajectory careers. 

Silver is a member of the American Association of University Women (AAUW) Alameda Branch where she focuses her efforts on increasing membership of community college women coming from exceptional backgrounds: student parents, low-income, and first-generation college students.

In her free time, she writes poetry and prose on emotional healing, radical acceptance, and patience. Writing has helped her process difficult situations and connect with people on a deeper level.

Jane Mortimer

Jane is a breast cancer survivor and advocate dedicated to positively impacting the lives of women affected by the disease. Diagnosed with triple negative breast cancer in 2012, she participated in the I-SPY 2 trial at UCSF and has been cancer free for more than ten years.

Her advocacy journey began in 2003 at UCSF as a volunteer with the Patient and Family Cancer Support Center and Decision Support Services and she previously managed the Peer Support program at UCSF. Drawing on her experience in marketing and media strategy, she uses her skills to make a meaningful impact by supporting advocacy and research that improves outcomes for women living with breast cancer.

Jan Tomlinson

In March of 2023 , Jan was diagnosed with a large aggressive triple negative breast cancer and informed that her cancer was the” bad girl” of cancer and offered standard chemotherapy for 24 weeks. Devasted by the diagnosis Jan felt like she had a dire prognosis. After seeking several opinions, she opted to join a Clinical Trial program for her treatment. The trial consisted of significantly less chemotherapy, and monitored closely over a 12-week period, The data predicted a complete pathological response , and she then went immediately to surgery. Pathology reports supported that she had a successful outcome reaching PCR meaning the tumor was gone, and no residual cancer was found in the surrounding tissue or lymph nodes. Jan was thrilled when her surgeon advised her of the results. The experience made Jan want to give back and share information that she received when she was at a critical juncture in her diagnosis. She is so passionate about making sure that everyone knows that the standard of care is one treatment option.

As she says, “ clinical trials have to be on the table” Because she achieved PCR, she expects a great outcome. She wants to share her story and encourage other women to strongly consider and participate in clinical trials. Jan is a UCSF Patient Advocate, involved in several programs they lead. Jan also is a BLACC Cab Member. Jan recently was in Washington DC to participate on a panel on Clinical Trials for ISPY at the National Press Club. UCSF will be hosting the RISE Up For Breast Cancer event where Jan will share her experience with clinical trials.

Deborah Collyar

Deb is a connector who founded Patient Advocates in Research (PAIR) “where research meets reality,” bringing ideas and people together for medical advances that offer real results for diverse patients and families.

Her vast experience between the worlds of tech, communication, strategy, management, policy, and equity bridges gaps between patients, scientists, medical providers, payers, governments, and non-profits.

Deb infuses patient engagement into projects, gathers relevant patient input, and encompasses many diseases, programs and policies at grassroots, national and international levels through companies, academia, and governments.

Key patient insights are delivered throughout discovery, development, clinical trials, results reporting, data-sharing, standards, genomics, and into practice.

Her experience spans translational and clinical research, epidemiology, health outcomes, and health delivery research with academia, federal agencies, companies, and patient communities.